Getting Smashed
November 20, 2026/10 Kislev 5787/Shabbat Vayetze
Hevre/Friends, Last Sunday our family and a few close friends gathered for the unveiling of Andi’s mother, Mavis, z"l. Under blue skies and brilliant sunshine, we took turns remembering her sweetness, her laughter, her delight, her simplicity, her strength. This week we read of Jacob fleeing to Haran and stopping for the night. The text is ambiguous: he gathers “stones” for a pillow, but awakens to “the stone.” Our Sages teach that the many fused into one, foreshadowing how Jacob’s children and the twelve tribes they founded would bind together into one Jewish people. At the graveside I offered another reading, inspired by Mavis’ life. Mavis lived most of her years to the rhythms of family gatherings and friends around the table. Then came tragic losses. First her beloved husband Sydney, z"l, with whom she shared a legendary romance. Then her daughter, Andi’s sister Elyse, z"l, who died at 47. And then, like Jacob, Mavis left the only land she knew, South Africa, to come to America and join our family, so she would not live out her days alone. The beautiful life she had built shattered. And yet from those fragments she made a renewed life, grateful, joyful, whole. My favourite biblical scene is Moses smashing the tablets at Sinai. It holds many layers, but one moves me deeply: the Sages taught that the shards were carried in the Ark alongside the second, whole set. Their presence testified that the moments that undo us are as sacred as the moments that hold us together. For the humility they unleash. For the compassion they motivate. For the gratitude they cultivate. For the hope they inspire. It is the same wisdom as the Japanese art of kintsugi. Rapture within rupture. Wholeness found within our brokenness, not in spite of it. Perfection, symbolized by imperfection. Rebbe Nachman of Breslov drew a sharp line between atzvut, a heavy, sinking sadness, and lev nishbar, a broken heart. Sadness, he taught, closes us in. A broken heart reveals an ache for healing, a yearning for reconnection. Run from the first, he urged. But do not fear or deny the second. Embrace it for what it tries to teach. There is much in our world today, as Jews, as Americans, as earthlings, that fills us with dread. And each of us carries private struggles that can overwhelm us with sadness and fear. Maybe we can face it all as brokenhearted rather than hopeless. Maybe we can hold together the many stones beneath Jacob’s head and the single stone he raised as a monument, naming that place Bet El, the House of God. In that pairing is a glimpse of the wholeness that can yet emerge from brokenness. Of how we might reconfigure the pieces of our societies, and of our lives, when they come apart. Of the next wholeness we can conjure from the pieces we are always putting back together. As the Kotzker Rebbe taught, there is nothing so whole as a broken heart. Standing beside the headstone that marks where Mavis now rests, we could not forget the many stones of her life that fused into that singular, rooted, enduring monument. What a testament to her relentless courage. What a legacy to leave us all. Shabbat Shalom, Dini |
![]() |



Comments